Each month Pie +Tart bakes a super secret seasonal pie or tart for it's Secret Pie Society members. Delicious, gourmet, sweet OR savory flavor combinations, packed with wholesome, natural, hand selected, local ingredients. At the start of each month we will contact you, or the gift subscription recipient of your choice, to request a preferred pie pick-up date. Each pie is baked fresh for it's scheduled pick-up and will serve at least 6-8. Only when you take your Secret Pie Society pie home and open the box will your pie's filling be revealed. Each super Secret Pie Society Pie will be sure to surprise and delight. 

This membership is for 1x Pie per month for 12 months! That is ONE WHOLE YEAR of seasonal secret pies and the price includes sales tax as well as a BONUS $40 Pie + Tart gift card with it's first pie pick-up.

12 Month Secret Pie Society Membership

  • Each Secret Pie Society Pie box will include heating and or serving suggestions. Please refer to the card included in your pie box or call us at the store for any Secret Pie Society Pie queries you may have. We are ALWAYS happy to talk 'Pie'!

  • Each Secret Pie Society Pie box will include a list of ingredients used and may highlight local sources. Interesting details regarding the recipe history and or origins may also be included